Should I Sell My Property or Rent It Out Before Upsizing?

Should I Sell My Property or Rent It Out Before Upsizing?

Deciding whether to sell or rent out your current home before upsizing is a crucial financial and lifestyle choice. Both options come with advantages and challenges, and the best decision depends on your financial situation, market conditions, and long-term goals. Here's some factors for you to consider:

1. Understanding Your Financial Position


Before making a decision, take a close look at your affordability and financing options.

  • Selling: If you sell your current home, you can use the proceeds as a deposit for your next home, potentially reducing your mortgage borrowing.
  • Renting Out: Keeping your current home as a rental property could generate passive income, but you will need a buy-to-let mortgage or consent to let from your lender if you still have a mortgage.

Ask yourself: Do you need the equity from your current home to afford your next one? If yes, selling may be the better choice.



2. Evaluating the UK Property Market


The UK housing market fluctuates, so understanding current trends is vital.

  • If house prices are rising, keeping your property and selling later could mean higher profits.
  • If prices are stagnant or declining, it might be better to sell now rather than risk a lower sale price in the future.
  • The rental market is strong in many UK cities, meaning you could generate good rental income if demand is high in your area.

Check: How is the market performing in your specific location? London, Manchester, Birmingham, and other cities have different rental yields and price trends.



3. Rental Income vs. Being a Landlord


Renting out your property can provide a steady income, but it also comes with responsibilities and risks.

Pros of Renting Out:

✅ Passive income potential
✅ Property may appreciate in value
✅ You have a fallback option if your new home doesn't work out

Cons of Renting Out:

❌ Managing the property yourself can be very work intensive without the help of a letting agent.
❌ Tenant risks (void periods, non-payment, damage)
❌ Additional taxes and regulations (stamp duty on second homes, capital gains tax if selling later)

If you’re open to being a landlord and willing to invest in a good letting agent, renting out your property could be a smart investment.



4. Tax Implications & Costs


In the UK, owning two properties comes with additional tax considerations:

  • Stamp Duty: If you buy a second home before selling the first, you’ll pay a 3% surcharge on the purchase. However, if you sell within three years, you can reclaim it.
  • Capital Gains Tax (CGT): If you sell your rented property later, you may be liable for CGT on any profit made.
  • Income Tax: Rental income is taxable, though you can deduct expenses like maintenance and letting agent fees.

Factor in these costs before making your decision.



5. How Long Are You Upsizing For?


Consider your long-term plans:
  • If you’re upsizing permanently, selling may be simpler.
  • If you may downsize later, keeping your current property as an investment could be a great financial strategy.


Final Thoughts: Sell or Rent?


🔹 Sell if:
✔️ You need the funds for your next home
✔️ You don’t want the hassle of being a landlord
✔️ Market conditions suggest selling is more profitable

🔹 Rent out if:
✔️ You can afford to keep both properties
✔️ Your current home has strong rental demand
✔️ You’re open to allowing a letting agent to manage the property for you

Ultimately, the right choice depends on your financial situation, market conditions, and long-term goals. If unsure, consult a property expert to guide you through your options.

Still unsure what to do? Give us a call! 🏡
0121 681 6327


Get in touch with us

The UK property market is known for its ups and downs — and when things start to slow, many sellers begin to worry. Fewer enquiries, longer listing times, and more cautious buyers can make it feel like selling your home is suddenly an uphill battle.

Thinking of selling soon? Setting the right asking price can make or break your move. Here’s why overvaluing your home, even with the best intentions, can actually reduce its true market value and slow your sale.

Thinking of selling your home in November 2025? Don't let the chill put you off! With the right strategy and a dash of expert guidance from a local Harborne estate agent, you can achieve a fantastic sale. Let's explore how to make your property shine, even as the festive season approaches.

When you decide to move home, you want the process to feel exciting. Yet behind the scenes, the property world has become a target for money launderers, fraudsters, and people who try to pass themselves off as something they’re not. That’s why choosing an estate agent who takes compliance seriously is extremely important.